For years, Tim McGraw wasn’t just known as a chart-topping country music superstar. He was also the face behind a surprisingly successful line of men’s colognes. Starting with the launch of “McGraw” in 2008, his fragrances found favor among fans and casual buyers alike. They were described as masculine, warm, and unmistakably Southern—an olfactory extension of Tim himself. But somewhere along the line, these colognes faded from store shelves, quietly slipping into obscurity.